The Lost Demos - Toby Mac

Album Review: The Lost Demos by TobyMac

Release Date: May 8, 2020
Label: ForeFront Records / Capitol CMG
Runtime: 7 Songs, 24 Minutes

1. Album Overview

The Lost Demos is a rare and intimate glimpse into TobyMac’s creative process. This 7-track collection showcases raw, unpolished demos recorded between 2014 and 2018, offering a behind-the-scenes look at songs in their early stages. For fans, this album feels like an invitation into TobyMac’s studio, where ideas are born and shaped. Despite the stripped-down production, the heart of each track shines brightly, reflecting Toby’s signature blend of thoughtful faith-based lyricism and modern pop energy.

The album serves as both a treasure trove for long-time listeners and a testament to Toby’s consistent artistry over the years.

Score: 88/100 — A rare and heartfelt creative offering.

2. Technical Mastery

Since these tracks are demos, they lack the polished production and mixing of TobyMac’s studio albums. However, that rawness gives The Lost Demos its unique charm. The minimal instrumentation and vocal takes offer a fresh and vulnerable dimension to Toby’s music. Tracks like “On Your Own” and “Love of My Life” feature organic textures, where imperfections (like breathy vocals or rough edges) amplify their authenticity.

The collaboration with Mr. Talkbox on “Rich” stands out as one of the more refined demos, incorporating smooth grooves and a laid-back delivery. While not every demo feels complete, they highlight TobyMac’s instincts as a songwriter and performer.

Score: 85/100 — Unpolished but creatively engaging.

3. Artistic Depth

This project reveals TobyMac’s artistic vulnerability. Lyrically, themes of love, purpose, and perseverance thread the album together. Songs like “The Real You” (2018 Tru’s Song-Writing Demo) carry deep emotional weight, particularly knowing the family tragedy Toby would later face. Similarly, “Fighting for Your Heart” showcases his ability to write songs that are both personal and relatable.

The stripped-back nature of these demos allows listeners to connect more deeply with the content. Without heavy production, the lyrics and melodies take center stage, revealing TobyMac’s unwavering commitment to sharing hope and truth.

Score: 90/100 — Emotionally raw and lyrically rich.

4. Audience Appeal

The Lost Demos is a niche offering primarily aimed at devoted fans who enjoy TobyMac’s music and appreciate the behind-the-scenes process. It may not resonate as strongly with casual listeners looking for fully realized hits. However, for those invested in Toby’s journey, these songs feel personal and almost sacred—like finding handwritten journal entries.

Tracks like “Home” (2017 Pool-House Demo) and “Drivin’ Me” balance catchy hooks with introspective songwriting, making them accessible even in demo form.

Score: 84/100 — A must-listen for loyal fans; a unique offering for others.

5. Standout Moments

• “On Your Own” (2017 Writing Demo) – A strong opener that sets the tone with an inspiring message of faith and resilience.

• “The Real You” (2018 Tru’s Song-Writing Demo) – Deeply emotional, showcasing TobyMac’s gift for heartfelt songwriting.

• “Rich” (feat. Mr. Talkbox) – A groovy, soulful demo that stands out for its collaborative energy and smooth vibe.

• “Fighting For Your Heart” (2017 Snowed-In Demo) – A melodic highlight, full of raw honesty and Toby’s signature uplifting tone.

6. Final Verdict

The Lost Demos is not your typical TobyMac release—it’s more intimate, raw, and unfinished by design. For fans, it’s a rewarding experience that showcases the building blocks of Toby’s celebrated music. The demos highlight his lyrical brilliance and commitment to spreading hope, even in their incomplete form. This collection might not break new ground musically, but it’s a heartfelt offering for those who want to know the “real” TobyMac behind the polished hits.

Overall Score: 88/100 — A unique and honest glimpse into TobyMac’s creative process.

For Fans Of: dc Talk, Chris Tomlin, Matthew West, NEEDTOBREATHE

Key Tracks to Stream: “On Your Own,” “The Real You,” “Rich.”